Skip to main content

Module 9: Who Pushed Humpty Dumpty?


Summary: Were all nursery rhymes fabricated or were they simply unsolved crime mysteries? The only way we can find out is by following Binky. Who's Binky? Well, he's a cop, robbery detail in the Pinecone Division. We get to tag along with Binky as he investigates a break in at the Bears house, a missing person case of a witch who lived in a candy house, and property damage from a giant falling from the sky. See all the popular nursery tale mysteries get solved, where justice is served, and the crime rate in Pinecone drops.

Reference: Levinthal, D. & Nickle, J. (2012). Who pushed Humpty Dumpty? And other notorious nursery tale mysteries.  New York, NY. Schwartz & Wade Books.

Impressions: This book had me from, "My name's Binky. I'm a cop." I found the stories to be amusing and creative. To re-visit old nursery rhymes as crime mysteries greatly impressed me. I think that this book could be enjoyed by many age groups and not just younger kids. Adults and older kids would laugh at the revisions of the tales while children would delight in recalling their nursery rhymes. The illustrations of the book were colorful and detailed enough for clarity, but not enough to overwhelm the story. Its style was reminiscent of Noir storytelling. Character faces are easily scene and instantly recognizable. This book has everything for all to enjoy.

Professional Evaluation: David Levinthal and John Nickle's WHO PUSHED HUMPTY DUMPTY? AND OTHER NOTORIOS NURSERY TALE MYSTERIES considers everything from a missing wicked witch who vanishes from a candied cottage to whether Humpty really fell off the wall - or was pushed. Clues, leads, confessions and all the elements of good detective writing are woven into a story ages 4-8 will delight in. The Picturebook Shelf ...., Random House/Knopf, ages 4-8

Midwest Book review (2012). [Review for Who pushed Humpty Dumpty? And other notorious nursery tale mysteries]. Children's Bookwatch. Retrieved from http://libproxy.library.unt.edu:3574/index.php/jbookdetail/jqbookdetail?page=1&pos=0&isbn=9780375841958.

Library Use: I can easily see this as a good writing exercise for high school students.  The students should be able to identify each of the characters and recall their respective nursery rhymes. After reading the story, the students will then be challenged to re-write other nursery rhymes or fairy tales with a contemporary twist, while keeping true to the details of the tales. Then they could present their stories to the rest of the class.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Super Mutant Magic Academy

Summary: Emotionally up and down, socially in and out, self/worldly comprehension and confusion: characteristics of high school teenagers.  Such is the case for Wendy, Marsha, Frances, Gemma, Trevor, Trixie, Cheddar and many others, all students at the Super-Mutant Magic Academy.  These students have their cliques as well as their outsiders, their jocks and their performance artists, their hip teachers and their clueless ones, unrequited love and hidden agendas.  Everything your typical high school would have, except these students aren't just kids, they're mutants.  Some students are humans with special abilities, while others are evolved animals with human characteristics.  Yet despite their mutant status they all still suffer from typical teenage angst and concerns, which are all on full display by Jillian Tamaki.  Each character has their own journey to follow, but unfortunately not every issue gets resolved.  Reference : Jillian Tamaki (2016). SuperMutant Magic Acade

Kirby: King of Comics

Summary : The biography of Jacob Kurtzberg, aka Jack Kirby, aka the King of Comics.  From his lowly beginnings as a newspaper hawker to drawing comic book heroes, we see the man doing what he is good at doing: creating.  Creating stories, creating fantasy, creating characters, creating never before seen artistic illustrations, and creating comic book lore.  Yet, he did not necessarily do it out of love for his profession, but out of love for his family.  That love of family entails a man's responsibility of taking care of his loved ones, so Jack did.  Yes, he enjoyed what he did and he was good at it, but if Jack could have found a better way to earn money, he would have leaped at the chance.  During his time, the profession of comic book artist paid very little and received even smaller recognition.  Throughout his career, Jack craved respect, but seldom got it; however, this did not deter Jack from continuing to fight for it, no matter who the publisher was, or the format.  Ja

The Baker Street Four, Vol 1

Summary: Often times in a Sir Arthur Conan Doyle mystery involving Sherlock Holmes, the protagonist relied on the assistance of individuals that he referred to as the Baker Street Irregulars.  These "irregulars" were the people of the streets or in this case the children.  These kids were more than likely orphaned or abandoned to the streets of London, left to fend for themselves.  Despite their sordid lives, Sherlock saw them as invaluable and would consistently turn to them for help.  In The Baker Street Four , we follow three such children, Tom, Charlie, and Billy, along with their pet cat, Watson, on two of their own personal cases: The Blue Curtain and The Rabúkin Case. The children get to practice the techniques that they most likely learned from associating with Holmes and their own street-wise expertise in order to solve their mysteries, which it turns out to be a great help to those they're aiding.  As we get to know each of these kids, we learn that each one